• About Us
    • Disclaimer and Policies
  • Giveaways
  • Features
    • Pre-Order Deal Incentives!
    • Author Talk Podcasts
    • Flashback Friday
    • Whadda YA Know Wednesday

Fiction Fare

  • Banners
  • Reviews
  • Contact Us

Better Than Perfect by Melissa Kantor

February 13, 2015 by Jaime Leave a Comment

Better Than Perfect by Melissa KantorBetter Than Perfect by Melissa Kantor
(Website, Blog, Twitter, Facebook, Goodreads)Published by Harper Collins on February 17th 2015
Genres: Death & Dying, Family, Friendship, Love & Romance, Marriage & Divorce, Social Issues, Young Adult
Pages: 336
Format: ARC
Add This Book to Your Goodreads TBR
three-stars
From the acclaimed author of Maybe One Day, Melissa Kantor, comes a poignant coming-of-age story that skillfully captures the singular experience of being a teenage girl. This beautifully woven tale will appeal to fans of Jenny Han and Sarah Dessen.Juliet Newman has it all. A picture-perfect family; a handsome, loving boyfriend; and a foolproof life plan: ace her SATs, get accepted into Harvard early decision, and live happily ever after.But when her dad moves out and her mom loses it, Juliet begins questioning the rules she's always lived by. And to make everything even more complicated there's Declan, the gorgeous boy who makes her feel alive and spontaneous—and who's totally off-limits. Torn between the life she always thought she wanted and one she never knew was possible, Juliet begins to wonder: What if perfect isn't all it's cracked up to be?
On the outside Juliet has everything… the perfect family, the perfect grades, the perfect boyfriend… and a plan for her future.

Or so it seems
.
Juliet’s perfect plans start to crumble when her father moves out of their house and her mom seems to fall into a pit of despair. Everything she thought was important suddenly changes and maybe acing those SAT’s and going to Harvard were never really her goals.

And then she meets Declan on one of the worst nights of her life and she’s no longer sure what she wants.

This is my second Melissa Kantor book. I absolutely loved Maybe One Day… even though it made me sob like a baby. So I knew I was going to snatch up her next book as soon as I could, but I hate to say that this one fell flat for me for a couple of reasons.

Spoilers ahead so be warned – turn away!
(view spoiler)[
I hate cheating… I hate cheating stories and books and characters. I have my reasons. So I will admit that I don’t normally read them, and in the summary of this one, there is no hint that there will be cheating.

There is cheating.

So admittedly this colored my opinion immediately. Don’t get me wrong, I could probably tolerate this if, say, the character had to ultimately deal with the consequences of the actions taken. And that right there is my biggest issue with this story.

Juliet never once acknowledges what she did to her boyfriend… OF FOUR YEARS. She never owns up to her infidelity and she never apologizes for breaking his trust in her. They part ways at the end because he feels like he doesn’t know who she is anymore and they have different priorities and goals, but NEVER ONCE does she tell him what she did.

And that made me angry.

Again, I have my personal feelings on this, and that admittedly curtailed my enjoyment of the story. I just feel like there were no repercussions for her actions and it left a bad taste in my mouth… I spent the rest of the story waiting for her to come clean but it never happened. (hide spoiler)]

Another reason I didn’t love this one were the characters. I never found myself connecting with anyone. I really liked her boyfriend … what we got to know of him, and that I think was my problem. Everyone felt very superficially a part of her life. Even Declan who we’re supposed to believe she has this unbelievable connection with for some reason is never explored fully and in actuality they had very little involvement in the actual story.

What I will say is that Juliet’s character was definitely explored and developed wonderfully. I understood her struggles… the pressure she puts on herself to succeed and be this person that everyone wanted and expected her to be… never getting to fully explore the things that are out there that maybe might interest her more than what she’s currently doing. The extreme focus to be the best at everything and the stress that can cause and then add to that the feeling that your family is falling apart and you have no one to lean on. I get it. I got her … I just maybe didn’t agree with her choices or the fact that she never really owned up to something big.

That said, the story was interesting, the writing was amazing and it’s definitely worth a read if you’re a fan of Melissa Kantor.

Thank you to HarperTeen for the advanced copy in exchange for my honest thoughts!

 

About Melissa Kantor

I was born in New York City in 1970. And even though teachers never care about this, I'll give you my sign--Capricorn.

When I was in seventh grade, I told people I was going to be a writer. Then in college I got interested in other things, and after I graduated I started teaching, which I love. But ideas for stories kept popping into my head. One was an image of two girls walking down Montague Street (that’s the main drag in Brooklyn Heights) during their lunch period. They were best friends, only one of the girls was cooler and prettier and more successful with boys than the other one. They were talking about a party they’d been invited to, trying to decide if they wanted to go or not. Finally I decided I had to know what happened to them. Those girls became Jan and Rebecca, and their story is Confessions of a Not It Girl.

Website • Blog • Twitter • Facebook • Goodreads

Related Posts

  • Related Posts
  • Same Genre
  • 3 Star Books
Blog Tour: Wicked Saints by Emily A. Duncan
Smash & Grab by Amy Christine Parker
The Unfortunates by Kim Liggett
Fiction Fare
Review: Roar and Liv
Fiction Fare
Review : Sophie & Carter (Novella)
Thumbnail
Proof of Forever by Lexa Hillyer
Thumbnail
Waiting on Wednesday: The Tenderness of Thieves by Donna Freitas
Fiction Fare
Get Dirty Blog Tour
Thumbnail
The Boy Who Knew Everything by Victoria Forester
Thumbnail
Waiting on Wednesday Where Futures End by Parker Peevyhouse
Thumbnail
Assassin’s Heart by Sarah Ahiers
Autofocus by Lauren Gibaldi
Thumbnail
Atlantis Rising by Gloria Craw
Thumbnail
Wicked Restless by Ginger Scott
A Pack of Blood and Lies by Olivia Wildenstein

Filed Under: Book Review Tagged With: Reviewed By Jaime, Young Adult

About Jaime

Avid reader and book blogger, lover of music, writing, my kid & my cats. Master of sarcasm and snark and doing what makes me happy.

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • pinterest
  • bloglovin
  • custom1
  • goodreads
  • rss
  • custom2

Get Our Updates!

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

E-Book Deals!

E-Book Deals!


Author Talk

 photo author-talk_zpscsw6iy8a.png

Archives

What We’re Currently Reading

Jaime's bookshelf: currently-reading

The Trouble with Destiny
0 of 5 stars
The Trouble with Destiny
by Lauren Morrill
The Beginning of Everything
0 of 5 stars
The Beginning of Everything
by Robyn Schneider
Forget Tomorrow
0 of 5 stars
Forget Tomorrow
by Pintip Dunn

goodreads.com

Erin's bookshelf: currently-reading

Endure
0 of 5 stars
Endure
by Sara B. Larson
The Unquiet
0 of 5 stars
The Unquiet
by Mikaela Everett
Twist
0 of 5 stars
Twist
by Karen Akins

goodreads.com

Upcoming Reviews

None yet!

Ebates Coupons and Cash Back

Challenge Participant

Recent Comments

  • Lisa Loves Lit on Waiting on Wednesday: The Queens of Innis Lear By Tessa Gratton
  • bookbunny68 on Top Ten Tuesday: Books That Have Been On My TBR the Longest and I Still Haven’t Read
  • Kristy Petree on Top Ten Tuesday: Books That Have Been On My TBR the Longest and I Still Haven’t Read
  • MischaS_ on Cover Reveal: Beyond Pain by Kit Rocha
  • Maggie @ ReadingDiva's Blog on Blog Tour: Tempests & Slaughter by Tamora Pierce

Recent Posts

  • People We Meet on Vacation by Emily Henry
  • Flashback Friday: Blood and Sand by C.V. Wyk
  • Our Top Ten Most Anticipated Books to Screen Podcast Episode
  • Flashback Friday: The Highwayman (Victorian Rebels #1) by Kerrigan Byrne
  • Podcast Episode 81: #FicNews–March 2021

Recent Reviews

People We Meet on Vacation by Emily Henry
The Heiress Gets a Duke by Harper St. George
Crown of Bones (Amassia #1) by A.K. Wilder
Courting Trouble (Goode Girls Romance #2) by Kerrigan Byrne
Eventide by Sarah Goodman
All Scot and Bothered (Devil You Know #2) by Kerrigan Byrne
Deadly Curious by Cindy Anstey
Review: Rebel Spy by Veronica Rossi
The Court of Miracles by Kester Grant
A Dark and Stormy Knight (Victorian Rebels #7) by Kerrigan Byrne

Copyright ©2010-2015 Fiction Fare « All Rights Reserved « Site Design by The CreativeB « Login